Hitchcock 2004 attempts to settle the matter by advancing a diachronic dutch book argument hereafter ddb for. But the synchronic dutch book argument for the principal principle is mentioned less. Dutch book arguments have been invoked to defend various probabilistic norms of rationality. People often talk about the synchronic dutch book argument for probabilism and the diachronic dutch strategy argument for conditionalization. An abortion can lead to medical complications such as pelvic inflammatory disease, the risk of ectopic pregnancies and the like. In belief and the will, van fraassen employed a diachronic dutch book argument to support a counterintuitive principle called reflection. Thats perhaps because, in one sense, there couldnt possibly be such an argument. Jul 01, 2012 diachronic dutch book arguments anna mahtani. Arguments for and against abortion you need to know. We see it as one of the tasks for the formal part of this book to resuscitate a. Conceptual analysis an overview sciencedirect topics.
Diachronic dutch book arguments lse research online. Measuring policy controversy with discourse network analysis. Theorem diachronic dutch book theorem if there is an i and an a 2asuch that ia\d i 6 a\d i d i, then has a strategy that is. The basic idea behind the dutch book argument for probabilism has been used in defense of a variety of principles that purport to govern how beliefs should evolve over time. Dmitri gallow abstract a handful of wellknown arguments the diachronic dutch book arguments rely upon theoremsestablishingthat,incertaincircumstances,youareimmunefromsuremonetary loss you are not diachronically dutch bookable if and only if you adopt the strategy.
Here, i show that this argument is in tension with evidence externalism, i. Dutch book arguments philosophy oxford bibliographies. Parfits reasons and persons 1984 is an original book with startling. The book abortion and the conscience of the nation presents the argument that abortion involves unjust discrimination against the unborn. In chapter 3, i develop a new objection to the synchronic dutch book argument, which concludes that. Issn 00318108 full text not available from this repository. Typical assumptions in consumer choice theory rule. Citeseerx diachronic dutch book arguments for bounded. According to the ddba for plan conditionalization, if an agent does not plan by update by conditionalization. A dutch book against sleeping beauties who are evidential. Diachronic dutch book arguments stanford encyclopedia of. Resource guide on strengthening judicial integrity and capacity.
Diachronic definition in the cambridge english dictionary. Hitchcock 2004 describes a dutch book argument against the halfer position. Dutch book arguments assume that your credences match your betting prices. Ab several leading topics outstanding after john earmans bayes or bust. The action of putting a coin in a piggy bank, for example, will. Prochoice emphasizes the womans choice whether to terminate a pregnancy.
Diachronic dutch books thoughts arguments and rants. The remaining sections are devoted to extensions of the basic dutch book argument for the probability axioms to arguments for additional. Bradley and leitgeb argue that hitchcocks ddb argument fails. Dutch books and pragmatic consistency on close inspection, however, the inconsistency some dutch book defenders are talking about is less parallel to standard deductive inconsistency than one might have thought. Next, well turn to a diachronic dutch book argument which concerns how consistent our credences need to be with.
Arguing dialectically about abortion political animal magazine. Diachronic dutch book arguments mahtani, anna 2012 diachronic dutch book arguments. I argue that a suitably qualified version of reflection gets around the counterexamples. Dutch book arguments show that violating the bayesian updating rule would result in preference for combinations of diachronic bets that result in a sure loss over time teller, 1976. Appeal to strategic features of the betting scenario, or 2. Beyond defending the probability axioms as a constraint on rational credences, dutch book arguments have also been given to defend a variety of other norms including conditionalization principles that purport to govern belief change over time. In gambling, a dutch book or lock is a set of odds and bets which guarantees a profit, regardless of the outcome of the gamble. We should therefore give great consideration to her. Two types of objection to diachronic dutch book arguments 3.
The mathematics of dutch book arguments dutch book arguments purport to establish norms that govern credences that is, numerically precise degrees of belief. With the help of the arguments in sections 4 and 5, i will conclude in section 6 that some defenders of the epistemic deference to experts faces a dilemma. If reflection is not really a requirement for partial believers, then diachronic dutch book arguments including the one that supports conditionalization are undermined. The dutch book argument see also the related money pump argument shows that beliefs about probabilities must be quantitative and satisfy standard probability axioms. Avoiding dutch books despite inconsistent credences forthcoming in synthese. Bayesian epistemology dutch book arguments stanford. Proceedings of the xth research symposium of the dutch and.
I offer a diachronic dutch book argument in favor of. Diachronic dutch book arguments for bounded rationality. Diachronic dutch books and evidential import gallow 2019. Prolife proposes the right of the embryo or fetus to gestate to term and be born. Including the difference between synchronic and diachronic dutch books, and an explana. Some defend plan conditionalization by appealing to a diachronic dutch book argument ddba. The proposed exploitation setups share a common feature. But the reflection principle is vulnerable to numerous counterexamples. Reflection principle can be defended with a diachronic dutch book argument dba, but it is also defeated by numerous compelling counterexamples. Interestingly, the diachronic dutch book requires your values not to predictably change, which seemingly implies that you have to do something like the above if you value somethings preferences once it is fully human i. And david lewis diachronic dutch book argument aims to establish conditionalization, the norm that says that an agent ought to plan to.
In this dutch book, the bookie rst before beauty goes to sleep sells her a bet that costs 15 and. Pythagorean knowledge from the ancient to the modern. This is done by first assuming that people with subjective probabilities would be willing to take fair bets on the basis of these probabilities. The notion of consistency for partial belief springerlink. Levi on money pumps and diachronic dutchbook arguments. Nearly all abortions happen in the first trimester where the fetus is attached to the placenta and the umbilical cord to the mother. Modern abortion debate has a strange familiarity about it. It turns out there is a standard dutch book argument suggesting that under. Suppose that agent as degrees of belief in s and s written dbs and dbs are each.
Even for those who are not routinely persuaded by diachronic dutch book arguments, this one has some important. Conditionalization, on the other hand, is a diachronic. Sleeping beauty alistair isaac may 19, 2008 some actions are more sensative than others to the number of times they are performed. Dutch book arguments purport to establish norms that govern credences that is, numerically precise degrees of belief. The ramseyde finetti argument can be illustrated by an example. For example, i may be uncertain whether abortion is morally. However, probabilists may not espouse the further diachronic norm. I offer an argument for the principle of sufficient reason on the basis of. Jan 01, 2009 diachronic dutch book arguments seem to support both conditionalization and bas van fraassens reflection principle.
In each case, it is argued that the agent who violates the principle is subject to a dutch book. Many of the counterexamples that briggs describes briggs 2009, 64a 66 need to be adjusted to be effective against the rei ection principle. Van fraassen has formulated a diachronic dutch book argument for reflection, but other authors cite counterexamples to reflection that appear to undermine the credibility of diachronic dutch books. Specifically, he advances a ddb against 12 and then shows that no similar ddb can be used against the thirder. Nearly all abortions take place in the first trimester when a fetus is attached by the placenta and. From a synchronic idea to a variety of diachronic accounts. It seems then that diachronic dbas can lead us astray. Both articles present the kinds of arguments that people wishing to think seriously about abortion will have to consider. Some have defended this claim by means of a diachronic dutch book argument. Against this, a variant of the diachronic dutch book argument shows that perfectly rational agents always have perfectly sharp probabilities.
In englishspeaking countries, the sides involved in the debate are the selfdescribed prochoice and prolife movements. Dutch book arguments for jeffrey conditionalization are invalid. Dutch book arguments stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. This survey offers critical assessments of several kinds of dutch book arguments. Theorem diachronic dutch book theorem if s strategy is not a probability measure, then has a. In this dutch book, the bookie rst before beauty goes to sleep sells her a bet that costs 15 and pays out 30 if the coin lands tails. Jul 20, 2006 this argument reminds us that even in the abortion debate, we should regard the woman as a person and not just as a container for the foetus. Quantum conditional probability eprints complutense. Anna mahtani search for other works by this author on. It is suggested that the proposed exploitation setups share.
I suggest a way out of the trouble that builds on the work of several earlier authors. I will show in section 5 that gdp and ndp are incompatible with each other. Objections to diachronic dutch book arguments take two general forms. According to this argument, those who deny that fetuses have a right to life do not value all human life, but instead, select arbitrary characteristics such as particular levels of physical or psychological. Introduction in newcombs problem nozick 1969, a being offers two boxes, a and b. There and subsequently van fraassen has put forth reflection as a linchpin for his views in epistemology and the philosophy of science, and for the voluntarism firstperson reports of subjective probability are undertakings of commitments that he. Abstract hitchcock advances a diachronic dutch book argument ddb for a answer to the sleeping beauty problem. Some actions are more sensative than others to the number of times they are performed. It is associated with probabilities implied by the odds not being coherent in economics, the term usually refers to a sequence of trades that would leave one party strictly worse off and another strictly better off. An explication of the dutch book arguments for bayesian epistemology.
I defend a theory of diachronic identity guaranteed to have no c. So, my arguments leave open the possibility that some dutch book arguments e. Epistemic consistency for partial believers, the journal of philosophy 93, 450479. In chapter 2, i use the machinery developed in chapter 1 to rebut money pump or diachronic dutch book arguments, which draw conclusions about rational beliefs and preferences from premises about how rational agents will behave over time. The abortion debate is the ongoing controversy surrounding the moral, legal, and religious status of induced abortion. Reflection principle can be defended with a diachronic dutch book argument dba, but it is also. Diachronic dutch book arguments involve systems of bets placed at multiple points in time. Diachronic dutch book arguments for forgetful agents.
Here, i will only explore whether foreseeable dynamic exploitabilitywhich is exposed by diachronic dutch books can be used to support plan conditionalization. Anna mahtani, diachronic dutch book arguments philpapers. Diachronic dutch book arguments for bounded rationality, case. Levi on money pumps and diachronic dutch books philpapers. Common arguments for and against abortion thoughtco. Dutch book arguments bayesian epistemology youtube. Next, well turn to a diachronic dutch book argument which concerns how consistent our credences need to be with credences at earlier or later. Dutch books discussed in this paper are diachronic. Should we reject them en masseincluding lewiss diachronic dba for conditionalization. Dutch book arguments purport to show that rationality requires certain constraints on an agents subjective probabilities, on pain of the agent being susceptible to sure losses in corresponding bets. Section 4 is dedicated to providing diachronic dutch book arguments for gdp and ncd. Newcombs problem, causal decision theory, evidential decision theory, dutch book arguments, rati. Diachronic dutch bookmaking, stripped to its bare bones so to speak, uses what i shall call double trades.
One argument suggests that her degree of belief in heads should be, while a second suggests that it should be 12. Dutch book argument an overview sciencedirect topics. Examples of pragmatic arguments of this kind are synchronic dutch books, for the standard probability axioms, diachronic dutch books, for the more controversial principles of reflection and conditionalization, and money pumps, for the transitivity requirement on preferences. Many have claimed that unspecific evidence sometimes demands unsharp, indeterminate, imprecise, vague, or intervalvalued probabilities. The action of putting a coin in a piggy bank, for example, will produce the e. In a diachronic dutch book, the bets are o ered at di erent times. Jul 01, 2012 diachronic dutch book arguments diachronic dutch book arguments 20120701 00. I argue that this tension casts doubt on the idea that diachronic dutch books can be used to justify or vindicate updating plans. Prima facie, the argument for 12 appears to be stronger.
1690 158 1306 988 763 393 1295 1692 83 1602 1398 1184 928 1205 1295 908 1772 171 1253 716 307 1946 340 1349 144 597 905 1717 1114 547 215